Choosing the right hook is one of the most important keys to a great fly fishing day. There are many sizes and styles designed for different water conditions and fish. This guide shows you how various hook sizes work for different species—whether you’re after small trout or larger gamefish—and gives you practical tips to choose the best hook for your needs. With this information, you’ll be ready to make every catch count.
Understanding Fly Fishing Hook Sizes
In fly fishing, hooks are labeled with numbers, where bigger numbers mean smaller hooks. It might seem confusing because a size 12 hook is actually smaller than a size 10 hook. These hooks range from tiny #32 to bigger #2, giving anglers lots of choices for different flies and fishing situations.
The size of the hook is important because it affects how the fly acts in the water and how well you can hook and keep a fish. Different styles like dry flies, nymphs, and streamers need certain sizes to work best.
For catching trout with streamers or nymphs, people usually use hooks up to size #2, which is typically big enough for these flies. Picking the right hook size is key. It helps make your fly look more like real prey, which boosts your chances of catching fish.
Key Features of Fly Fishing Hooks
Fly fishing hooks are designed with special features; different types have different gaps, shanks, and/or eyes to make them work better. Let’s take a closer look at each part of the hook.
Hook Gap
The hook gap is the space between the hook point and the shank. It’s a big deal because it can affect how well you hook the fish. Some anglers like bigger hook gaps because they make it easier to catch more fish. But keep in mind, hook gaps can vary between brands even if they have the same number.
This gap is key when picking a hook size and determining how well it will catch the fish you’re targeting. Understanding its importance helps you choose the right hook size, whether you’re using barbless or jig hooks. It’s crucial for matching your fly patterns to different fishing conditions.
Hook Shank
The hook shank is the straight part of the hook that goes from the eye to just before the bend. Shanks can be different lengths, and longer ones are measured as 1.5x or 2x compared to regular hooks, sometimes even going up to 9XL for certain fly patterns (like the Blue Devil, Pink Lady, and Gray Ghost for example). These long shanks help create longer bodies for flies, usually streamers that mimic baitfish.
Curved shanks can help your fly look like insect larvae, pupae or small crustaceans, making them great for those types of patterns. Some hooks have tapered shanks for tying specific fly designs that imitate baitfish, like streamers and baitfish patterns. Knowing these options helps anglers pick the right hook for their fishing needs.
Hook Eye
The hook eye (where you attach your fishing line) is made from the same wire as the hook. How it’s made can affect the kind of knot you’ll want to use to tie on your fly. Picking the right leader and tippet sizes is important to make sure the hook eye works well in keeping the fly secure.
There are 3 different types of hook eyes:
- Turned up
- Turned down
- Straight (ring eye)
There’s also open, closed, and looped hook eyes, each suited for specific fishing styles.
Knowing when to use each type of hook eye can really boost your fishing success.
- Straight Eye – Best for nymphs and streamers when you want a direct, straight-line pull for better hook penetration. Works well with loop knots for natural movement.
- Downturned (Down-Eye) – Ideal for dry flies and traditional nymphs, offering a better angle for hooking fish. Common in classic patterns.
- Upturned (Up-Eye) – Often used on salmon and wet flies, especially with snells or snelled leaders, to improve the hook-set angle.
- Ring Eye – A versatile option found in many hook styles, good for various knots and offering a more direct pull.
- Loop Eye – Helps create more realistic fly movement, common in some classic and modern patterns.
Now that we’ve covered hook eyes, let’s dive into the different types of fly fishing hooks.
Types of Fly Fishing Hooks
There are many kinds of fly fishing hooks, each built to work best with certain fly patterns and fishing conditions. Knowing the differences between dry fly, nymph, and streamer hooks can help you pick the right one for the fish you’re after and the environment you’re fishing in.
Dry Fly Hooks
Dry fly hooks are made for flies that float on top of the water. They typically have a shorter shank and are made from lighter wire, which helps the fly stay buoyant. This design is key for keeping your fly on the surface where many fish feed. It’s a good idea to have a range of sizes and colors in your dry fly collection since fish can be picky based on local insect activity. Classic patterns like Elk Hair Caddis and Parachute Adams are must-haves for many fly fishers.
Nymph Fly Hooks
Nymph hooks are designed for flies that imitate the early life stages of aquatic insects. These hooks usually have a down-eye and come in both straight and curved shapes. Nymph hooks usually come in sizes between 10 and 18 to suit a range of nymph styles.
When you tie smaller nymph patterns, you can use hook sizes ranging from 18 to 22. The Prince Nymph and Pheasant Tail patterns for example, you can create on hooks ranging from 12 to 20. Patterns like the Zebra Midge closely mimic the look of real midge larvae, and work very well as a result. You can tie them on 18 to 20 size hooks, their most common sizes.
When choosing a nymph hook, consider the types of insects common in your fishing spot and pick a hook size that matches the fly pattern you’re using.
Streamer Hooks
Streamer hooks are used for flies that resemble baitfish or larger aquatic creatures. They often have a long shank and are made from thicker wire, which makes them strong enough to handle bigger fish. The longer shank also helps create movement in the fly—an important factor in attracting fish.
Streamer flies often use hook sizes such as 8 and 10, which offer flexibility across various fishing scenarios. For streamer designs and sizable flies, bigger hooks ranging from size 2 to 4/0 are preferable to enhance the effectiveness of the hook set while angling.
Flies like the Muddler Minnow work well at luring a range of species including most trout, smallmouth bass, and largemouth. Alongside the Wooly Bugger and Muddler Minnow, they’re essential streamers to have in your collection.
It’s useful to have a variety of streamer hook sizes and styles so you can adapt your setup to different fishing scenarios and better mimic the natural prey of your target fish.
Choosing the Right Hook Size
The selection of the appropriate hook size is impacted by several elements, including the species of fish you’re fishing for, the specific fly employed, and the current conditions in the water. Making an informed decision on hook size can markedly improve your prospects for a successful fishing outing.
Match the Hatch
Watching the insects and other prey near your fishing spot can help you choose the right fly to match the hatch. Make sure your fly matches the size and shape of the critters your target gamefish is feeding on. Using a simple net to catch a sample of the wildlife in your fishing hole lets you see what types are around and how big they are. Since different seasons bring different sizes, shapes and types of prey, this can help you pick the right fly for the time of year. Also, get advice from your local fly fishing shop on what’s catching fish right now and where (and when and how). For example, if they tell you small insects like midges are working best right now, you can use smaller flies (sizes 18-26) imitating midges.
Fish Species
It’s important to know what different fish like to eat and what size prey they prefer. When you’re dry fly fishing for trout, hooks between size 12 and 16 or so work well, with size 14 being a favorite in many trout streams.
If you’re using larger patterns like streamers, try hook sizes between 8 and 12. For common nymphs like mayfly and dragonfly larvae, sizes 12-16 can be great. Always ask the guides and staff at your local fly shop though, because there are many details that go into selecting the ideal flies and sizes. They’ll have a better understanding of this than pretty much anyone else.
Water Clarity
When the water is clear, fish (especially trout) tend to be more cautious and often shy away from bigger hooks because they look less natural, less real. Use smaller hooks to increase your chances of catching fish.
Understanding how water clarity affects your choice of hook size can help you make better decisions and improve your chances of a successful catch.
New Hook Designs for Everyday Anglers
In recent years, many fly fishers have switched to new hook designs like barbless and jig hooks. The barbless design supports ethical catch-and-release practices, and the jig design has benefits of its own that we’ll discuss below. Below, we’ll explore the benefits of these hooks and explain why more fly fishers are choosing them.
Barbless Hooks
These hooks are made without the little barb that regular hooks have. These hooks make it easier to take the hook out of the fish and cause less harm. Using these hooks help a lot when you want to release fish back into the water without harming them.
In fly fishing contests around the world, anglers have to use barbless hooks. The same is true in many rivers and fisheries. This rule highlights how important these hooks are for letting fish go safely after catching them.
Jig Hooks
Jig hooks are becoming more popular for a few reasons. Part of it is because their design positions the hook point upwards, which helps keep the fly from getting caught on underwater obstacles. For some water conditions this can be very helpful.
Sidenote: The jig isn’t the only pattern that achieves this; almost all nymphs invert, in particular when they’re weighted with lead or a bead.
Jigs also provide lifelike vertical fly action, the classic “jigging” ability, and ample weight, which can help your fly sink to the ideal depth faster. Keep in mind, in fly fishing only waters and competitions, jigs are often banned because they’re not considered a proper fly.
Materials and Finishes of Fly Fishing Hooks
Fly fishing hooks come in different materials, and each type has its own perks. Picking the right one depends on where you fish and how you take care of your gear.
Carbon Steel Hooks
Carbon steel hooks are well-known for their toughness and long-lasting strength, which makes them a favorite for freshwater fishing. They can take a beating and still hold up well. But they do require a bit of extra care—if you don’t clean and dry them after each use, they can rust. Even with the need for regular upkeep, many anglers stick with carbon steel because they work hard and last a long time when properly maintained.
Stainless Steel Hooks
Stainless steel hooks offer a huge advantage when it comes to fighting rust. This makes them a great choice for saltwater fishing, where the salty environment can rapidly corrode other types of hooks.
They stay sharp and effective over time, even in harsh conditions. For those who fish in the ocean or other saltwater spots, stainless steel hooks provide a dependable option that requires less worry about corrosion. They’re generally considered slightly weaker than carbon steel hooks.
Coated Hooks
Coated hooks come with a protective finish that helps keep rust and corrosion at bay. This extra layer means they can last longer, even if you’re not able to give them as much care as carbon steel hooks.
While they still need some cleaning after use, the coating adds durability and helps your hooks stay in good shape over time. This makes coated hooks a smart choice for anglers who want gear that can handle regular use with less maintenance.
Final Thoughts
Understanding fly fishing hook sizes and features is a fundamental many anglers overlook, but it’s key to catching more fish. We’ve covered everything from how hooks are numbered and designed to the best sizes for common fly patterns.
By choosing the right hook and pattern, you’ll quickly boost your fishing success. And when you’re ready to put these tips into action, join one of our guided tours for expert advice and hands-on learning.
Grab your gear, head out, and enjoy the adventure!
Did you enjoy this post? You’ll probably like this one too:
Sierra Fly Fisher Guided Tours: Put Your Knowledge to Work
Now that you know how to choose the ideal hook, test your skills on the water. Our guided tours in Northern California are the perfect way to put your knowledge into practice. With over 29 years of experience, our guides create trips for individuals, families, friends, and groups, offering hands-on advice—down to the perfect hook and pattern—to boost your catch rate.
Our trips give you access to top fishing spots known for wild trout, including the Upper Tuolumne and Merced Rivers in Yosemite, as well as the San Joaquin, Kings, and Kaweah Rivers. Fishing with us isn’t just about catching fish; it’s a chance to explore the beautiful wilderness around you and gain practical flyfishing knowledge that can make all the difference.
