Matching the hatch is simple but not always easy. It’s just choosing fly patterns that mimic the insects and other prey fish are currently eating. This is an absolute must for successful fly fishing.
You can often get away with generalist flies like the wooly bugger because they’re bound to match some part of the hatch since they can mimic so many things (depending on how you fish it, it could be a minnow, leech, crayfish, etc). But without evolving your game plan to match the specific hatch in the water right now, you’ll end up wading through numerous dry spells.
In this article, we’ll cover how to identify these insects, recognize different hatches, and select the best flies to match the hatch and improve your catch rate.
Mastering the Art: The Best Ways to Match the Hatch
Let’s talk about how to accurately imitate the prey that wild trout and other game fish are feeding on during a hatch. Recognizing and mimicking these specific insects is crucial to increase your chances of a good catch, whether fishing with wet flies or dry fly fishing.
What Are They Feeding on?
The process starts with figuring out what the trout, smallies, or other gamefish are feeding on. Then you select the appropriate fly patterns to match that prey, to catch trout and other gamefish. If they’re feeding below the surface, you’ll need a wet fly, and if they’re rising to nab insects off the top of the water, dry flies are your best bet.
Gather Info From Your Local Fly Shop & Fly Fishers
The weather and season heavily influence insect life and fish behavior, and hatches vary across regions throughout the year. We’ll get into this more soon, but as a quick tip, your best bet is to speak with the best flyfishers in your area and ask them what trout are eating the most right now. Eventually, you’ll recognize patterns and remember what happened last year. (What happens when the temperature, weather, and season are similar, for example).
Your local fly shop is the best place to gather this information because the guides and fly fishers working there love giving good advice. And the advice is quite good because they typically know the local waters better than anyone.
Pay Attention to the Ecosystem & Watch for Patterns
The second foundational tip is to pay close attention to the ecosystem around you as you fish. Look into the water, overturn a rock or two, and see what scurries away. Look closely at the grass next to the water, and observe what’s floating on the water. Even well before you know what hatches happen and when, you can simply choose the bug in your box that looks the most like, say:
- The grasshoppers you notice jumping around a lot more than usual
- Or the twirly little critters that scuttled away when you moved a rock in the water
- Or the cicadas you hear singing and molting in the trees around you
- The prey in the stomach of the fish you catch (stomach pumping is another method you can use to inspect a trout’s stomach contents to determine its diet)
- The small, dark nymphs clinging to the rocks you overturned
- The baitfish darting near the shallows or hiding in aquatic vegetation
- The dragonfly or damselfly nymphs that crawl along submerged rocks and vegetation
- The crayfish scurrying on the riverbed
- The terrestrial insects, like caterpillars or crickets, you see getting blown into the water
Understanding the seasonal timing, hatch patterns, and the life cycles of specific insects will eventually increase your success. But until then, observe and match what you can. Follow the advice of your local fly shop owners and guides. Try noticing the real-life versions of the pattern that’s working so well now. This will help you gain a better understanding of how it all works.
Map the Hatch (Use Hatch Charts)
What if you could see which insects fish are eating based on the time of year? With a good chart, that’s the flyfishing superpower you’ll have. One of the most helpful things you can do is plot a chart, or use a chart developed by flyfishing veterans.
The timing of hatches is well-documented in guidebooks and mobile apps. You might find the Flyfisher’s Guide series for your area particularly useful. But there are many valuable books with brilliant hatch charts. And if you prefer apps, search for “hatch charts” on your Apple or Android device. You’ll find a few solid tools including apps with hatch charts. 
Flyfishing hatch chart example.
Understanding “Match the Hatch”
During aquatic insect hatches, fish and especially trout feeding activity increases significantly. During a hatch, trout target this plentiful food supply and often overlook other prey. “Matching the hatch” requires selecting the flies that closely resemble the specific insects in the hatch and their stage of development, to align with the natural predatory habits of trout.
The emergence of different insect species and subsequent feeding patterns in trout are heavily influenced by seasons and weather conditions, which affect both when and how intensely these insect hatches happen. Different geographic locations have fly hatches throughout the year, with differing insects and prey.
Identifying Aquatic Insects
To master matching the hatch, start identifying the aquatic insects in your local waters. Tips from the fly fishing shop are a great start, but we highly recommend hands-on experience. Nothing beats the experiential understanding that comes from seeing what the fish are feeding on up close, in person, even holding them in your hand.
Practical techniques like using seine nets to catch these insects and baitfish (take note of the size, color, and shape) or flipping rocks to uncover nymphs and crayfish are effective ways of identification. If you can see the insects on the surface, wait and watch to see if you can identify trout rising to feed on the insects. This is an especially valuable piece of info.
Once you pinpoint which insects are prevalent and likely the main course for your local trout or game fish, proceed by meticulously comparing them against your fly box assortment and select the most precise matches in color, size, shape, and overall look. Let’s cover some of the most important hatches to match.
Caddisflies
Flyfishers place high importance on caddisflies, and with good reason. You can recognize them by their body shape, elongated antennae, and distinctive wings. As key prey items for numerous fish species, these insects emerge predominantly in the spring and through fall on many streams and rivers, ensuring a steady food supply for trout. It’s essential to note that there are two primary types of caddis nymphs—cased and uncased—and both are critical when choosing the right fly.
Caddisfly hatches capture significant attention from flyfishers because they occur frequently and provide ample opportunity to hook into fish. Consequently, it’s a fairly standard practice for flyfishers to equip their fly boxes with an assortment of caddisfly imitations in preparation for the hatches during the various stages.
Mayflies
Fly anglers place great importance on mayflies, a significant group of aquatic insects with over 600 species found in the United States. Recognized by their tender wings held aloft, the unique phases of their life cycle, and their hatching in May (but also many different times, depending on the species; June, July, and even August as well).
To maximize your catch, understanding where mayflies live and behave is vital. These insects will often emerge en masse during hatching events, becoming the perfect buffet for trout and bass. Anglers who successfully mimic the different stages of the mayfly’s life cycle will substantially enhance their odds of hauling in a successful catch.
Stoneflies
Stoneflies belong to the order Plecoptera. They represent a vital subset of aquatic insects for fly fishers for the same reasons as Mayflies and Caddisflies. These insects spend their nymphal stage on the bottom of streams amidst rocks and gravel beds. Due to their substantial size and rich protein levels, stoneflies are highly appealing as a food item for trout.
When stoneflies begin hatching, these nymphs migrate to shore to hatch. Trout can become exceptionally aggressive in their feeding habits during this time, and matching this hatch becomes key for catching fish. Fly fishermen exploit this – you guessed it – choosing fly patterns that resemble the nymph stage of stonefly life cycles to improve their odds.
Tools for Matching the Hatch
To successfully match the hatch in fly fishing, all you need are your eyes (to spot the bugs), your ears (to listen for advice on which bugs are hatching), and your flies (to mimic the bugs). But to take it to the next level, you need the tools of the trade.
Hatch-Matching Tools of the Trade
Seine nets, sample vials, and thermometers specifically designed for fly fishing are indispensable for gathering and recognizing samples of local aquatic insects. Use these tools to gain insights into the local insect populations and choose suitable fly patterns accordingly. Let’s start with the thermometer.
Fly Fishing Thermometer
The behavior of aquatic insects is heavily influenced by water temperature. The reaction to temperature shifts varies among different species of aquatic insects, and recognizing these trends can greatly enhance an angler’s choice of flies.
You’ll get to the point where you’ll know what various insects (and thus trout) are doing without seeing them. Thanks to the patterns you’ve observed over time. As a budget-friendly option, you can get standard thermometers for fly fishing for less than $20.
By monitoring water temperatures, you can anticipate the timing and location of insect hatches. This boosts your chances for fruitful outings on the water. If you’re looking for a technique to get to the next level in your match-the-hatch game, gauging the temperature is one great way. And nets can be even better.
Seine Nets
Seine nets are pivotal for capturing live aquatic samples, from insects to baitfish, crayfish, and more. And this is key to synchronizing with hatches effectively, and knowing what patterns to use when there are no visible hatches to match.
A good net will help you scrutinize the native insects and other critters in your local ecosystem so you can tailor your fly choices to match them. Mimic prevalent species of insects, fish, and other prey that fish are naturally eating. This direct method is a flyfisher favorite for a reason.
Sample Vials
Preserving insects in sample vials is great, especially when you tie your own flies. It contributes to thorough examination and identification, enhances pattern recognition, and helps you mimic more specific details with the patterns you tie or choose.
Perhaps most importantly, you can observe the insects in the streamwater you collect in the vial. This gives you a much more accurate pinpointing of the nuances in color, which you can’t see observing the bugs in your hand or the seine net.
Common Terrestrial Insects
Terrestrial insects, including grasshoppers, cicadas, ants, and beetles typically reside on land but can inadvertently find themselves afloat on the water’s surface. When gusty conditions or storms occur, these insects are often swept into aquatic environments where they become yet another delicious option in the organic buffet of the stream.
Recognizing how crucial terrestrial insects are to a trout’s nutritional intake is beneficial for anglers. This knowledge assists them in selecting appropriate fly patterns that enhance their likelihood of making an effective catch.
Grasshoppers
During the warmer months, grasshoppers are a significant source of high-protein nourishment for trout due to their abundance. These insects possess distinctive long hind legs that grant them an impressive jumping ability, potentially making them more attractive to fish. As summer progresses, these insects typically congregate close to the edge of water bodies, presenting an abundant food source for trout.
Fly fishermen frequently utilize larger patterns resembling grasshoppers to lure bigger fish when casting near banks and vegetation-rich zones. Particularly towards the late summer period when grasshopper populations peak, these imitations become a staple strategy amongst anglers targeting trout.
Ants and Beetles
Terrestrial insects like ants and beetles, commonly located near aquatic environments, can be successful bait for fly fishing when they accidentally end up in the water. As these insects flounder on the water surface, they become key “food targets” for fish such as trout, which are drawn to their struggles.
Using fly patterns that replicate ants and beetles tends to yield results, especially when these species are abundant. Anglers who have insight into various ant and beetle behaviors and their visual characteristics can refine their choice of flies and enhance their chances of catching lots of fish.
Presenting the Fly
Presenting your fly is just as critical as choosing the ideal pattern. Trout commonly feed within designated zones called feeding lanes, where they await food delivered by the water flow. The first step is placing your fly properly in those feeding lanes, where hungry trout can see it. The second step is fly movement, which will change with the prey you’re mimicking.
Watch & Mimic
Do your best to watch the behavior of the insect you’re going to imitate, even if all you can find is a YouTube video. Watch nymphs’ swimming patterns, then twitch your fly in the shallows to see if you can get it to look the same. Watch grasshoppers struggling on the surface, and twitch your hopper pattern on the water to mimic that kick-kick-pause sort of pattern.
Use the Most Effective Colors
And a quick word on color. Most aquatic insects are brown, olive, cream, or gray. So when in doubt, choose one of those colors. (Especially if you’re fishing clear waters where the fish can see exceptionally well, and are more cautious and picky than usual.)
A Natural Presentation is Key
Here’s another presentation tip. To increase your chances of catching fish, cast slightly beyond your target and let the current naturally guide your fly into their feeding lane. Use techniques like reach casting or mending to create a drag-free drift and keep the fly moving naturally downstream.
Local Fly Shop Resources
One more thing about leveraging expert advice. Flyfishers can greatly benefit from the wisdom and tailored services provided by local fly shops. These establishments are a goldmine of guidance. They offer specific patterns of flies that match well with the local insect hatches.
The experienced staff and guides at these shops will help you understand the complex dynamics of local insects and help you nail down the best fly selections to align with ongoing hatches. And better still, if you’re able, hire a guide to fish with, and pick their mind for a day as you catch fish. But whether you’re fishing with a guide or chatting with the flyfishers at your local fly shop, you need to know what to ask them.
Here’s a list of some of the best questions to ask:
- What flies are the fish hitting right now?
- Which insect hatches are happening this week? Where?
- What’s the best time of day to fish in this area?
- What fly sizes are working best right now?
- Are there any specific fishing techniques or presentations I should use?
- How’s the water flow and clarity today?
- What are the best spots or stretches to fish around here?
- Should I focus on nymphs, dries, or streamers during this week/month/season?
- Are the fish holding deep or staying near the surface?
- Do you recommend any particular leader or tippet setups for today’s conditions?
To Sum It Up
Perfecting the technique of matching the hatch can elevate your fly fishing ability from average to exceptional. Gaining an insight into the patterns and developmental stages of aquatic insects allows you to choose and present an irresistible fly, captivating even the pickiest trout. By recognizing various species like caddisflies, mayflies, and stoneflies and employing tools like thermometers, seine nets, and sample vials, you’ll enhance your ability to see vital patterns and accurately match hatches.
Excelling at fly fishing is not about great gear as much as it is about consistent observation and adjusting to nature’s rhythm. Frequent visits to your local fly shop for advice from seasoned anglers will help you stay abreast of local hatches and the most effective patterns and presentations to test. Good luck and tight lines!
Did you enjoy this post? You’ll probably like these too:
- When to Use a Dry Fly vs a Wet Fly & Key Differences
- Mastering Your Fly Rod Setup: A Step-by-Step Guide
Ready to Elevate Your Fly Fishing Experience?
If you’re eager to refine your skills and enjoy a successful day on the water, we invite you to schedule a guided fishing trip with Sierra Fly Fisher. Our expert guides are here to provide tailored experiences that cater to your interests and skill level. Don’t miss out—reach out today and let us help you master the art of fly fishing!